šŸ”¬ the 14 day LinkedIn experiment

test, measure + debunk the data (with my actual LinkedIn as proof!)

table of funtents

As a reminder, I started building keshty in public because:

- Most of us donā€™t come from a long line of entrepreneurs (me included)

- I wanted to equip minority misfits with tools to scale their own impact

- HENCE, I needed to live transparently (no BS) through my own journey

šŸ‘‹šŸ¼ itā€™s me, hi

HI MISFITS!

BOY AM I GLAD TO SEE YOU ALL TODAY (truly, the highlight of my week).

Iā€™m afraid the state of the world isnā€™t much brighter since we last spoke.

A number of global changes (most notably, the American inauguration) have left many (including me) with big feels.

Before we dive into episode 12, Iā€™ll leave you with this: as the name suggests, this is a safe and welcome space to celebrate minority misfits.

In a world currently threatening some of our most fundamental rights, I hope you find comfort knowing these weekly nuggets encourage doing things differently and succeeding because of, rather than in spite of, our unique idiosyncrasies.

Yā€™all are welcome here.

if all else fails

ICYMI:

  1. I posted a plea for happy news (e.g. dog photos) on LinkedIn yesterday, and the people DELIVERED 

  2. Last weekā€™s episode was all about pricing your services (the question most of you asked @ sign up stage!)

Now, letā€™s dive into episode 12.

Episode summary: Girl meets Boy. They fall in love. Girl falls out of love and into visceral loathing. Girl leaves Boy for 2 months. Girl returns to conduct a 14 day experiment to see if she can fall back in love again.

These are the results of said experiment.

šŸ”¬ the 14 day LinkedIn experiment

I often mention how instrumental LinkedIn is to keshtyā€™s build + success.

LinkedIn offers:

  1. a free platform to market yourself and your personal brand

  2. a space to develop your writing, connecting and learning skills

  3. the opportunity to engage with a WHOLE WORLD you otherwise couldn't

From 25 September 2023, I consistently posted 3-5x a week for one year*

Once I passed the one year mark, though, something changed:

I started viscerally loathing LinkedIn.

I went from having ā€œitā€™s not that deepā€ tattooed on my forehead to taking everything more seriously than I cared to. I felt myself:

  1. miss learning from real people through their eloquent, medium-form writing vs. bots, random selfies and recycled videos on other social media apps

  2. bored by the same people in the same engagement pods oozing over each otherā€™s content vs. authentic, thought-provoking engagement

  3. expend energy trying to keep bad vibes out of my writing / overthinking what didnā€™t matter e.g. ā€œhooksā€ instead of just writing as myself

So I took two months off, recalibrated and decided to bring it back to something I love: trial and data (trial and errorā€™s more informed 2nd cousin).

PS: thanks to this experiment, Iā€™m actually more excited to get back into LinkedIn than I was at the start. Read on!

1. the content

I primarily write about one topic on LinkedIn: scaling diverse, high-performing teams.

Itā€™s where most of my ideal Fractional / Advisory prospects lurk, so naturally, I want to speak to their pain points where I know they hang out.

Posts always differ slightly, as sometimes Iā€™ll:

  • focus on one element: e.g. scale, diverse or high-performing

  • talk about how fractionals help founders achieve the same results

  • post to re-intro my experience, leadership style and offer to readers

*on rare occasions (<5% of posts), Iā€™ll either share something personal / helpful but unrelated to my key topic.

2. the experiment

For this mini-experiment, I wanted to explore 3 things:

  • topic: 95% content linked back to my main topic, 5% other

  • cadence: test active vs. inactive posting with 7 days on (my own posts), 7 days off (comments or sharing otherā€™s posts only)

  • post type: thereā€™s SO much speculation about text / images / videos (mobile or desktop configured) / links (in posts or comments) - so why not try them all?

Hereā€™s what my 14 day post calendar looked like:

week 1: I posted 3 days on, 4 days off

week 2: I posted 4 days on, 3 days off

3. the data

Iā€™ll present results in two ways (pick your preference!):

  • visual: screenshots of my LinkedIn analytics between 6-19th Jan

  • numerical: table with raw data points against each post

Across both, weā€™ll look at:

  • engagements: post interactions (likes, comments, shares)

  • impressions: the number of times your post was displayed on screen

  • follower count: LI analytics donā€™t include unfollows, but always assume some!

i. visual

fyi: screenshots taken on 19 Jan @ 5 pm

engagement data; the highest-performing day being my comeback

impressions data; the highest-performing day being 16 Jan (both post 5+6 had a spike in impressions that day)

follow data; the highest-performing day being 15 Jan with 19 followers

ii. numerical

fyi: raw data taken today 22 Jan @ 2pm. done intentionally to show you posts can bake, donā€™t entirely depend on ā€œthe first hourā€ and still make rounds at the weekends

post topic (linked)

date posted

post type*

impression data

engagem-ent data

followers**(gained between post # and next post)

1. Iā€™m back

mon 6th

text only

6,701

189

11

2. news-letter

tues 7th

text + link in post

1,517

47

13

3. LA fires

thurs 9th

text, image + link in comments

2,888

96

24

4. re-intro

mon 13th

text + image

1,128

42

9

5. fCOO cash vs. equity 

tues 14th

text + tags in post

7,165

105

32

6. LI data

thurs 16th

text first + video (for desktop)

6,476

140

13

7. growth vs. scale

fri 17th

video first (for mobile) + text caption

1,847

80

27

* text only / first posts performed better. guessing because I enjoy writing significantly more than photo / video, it prob comes through in post quality

** 129 new followers in 2 weeks: most came through on the weekend, meaning posts still make the rounds days (even weeks!) after

šŸ’© no bs reminders

šŸš¦ if in doubt, just start

Letā€™s take easy numbers: say youā€™re averaging 10k impressions and 25 net gained followers (total follows + unfollows). After one year, youā€™ll hit over half a million impressions and 1.3k new followers.

That may not seem like much when comparing yourself to peeps boasting exponential growth stats (theyā€™re lying, btw). But could you imagine 1300 people crowding a room to hear what you have to say?

Only 1% of LinkedIn actively posts weekly, so if youā€™re thinking of starting - just do it. If your hurdle is time, make it. If your hurdle is ideas, pick a topic, do a braindump and make 5x posts out of it. If your hurdle is feeling cringe, I feel ya - but youā€™re leaving money, friendships and opportunities on the table. If in doubt, just start.

šŸ—£ļø embrace comments

Stop commenting on Steven Bartlett or Alex Hormoziā€™s posts, yā€™all. No beef, but theyā€™re not going to engage back, their posts are surrounded by comment bots and youā€™re competing with thousands of overly keen users.

With that said, Iā€™ve found comments to be a seriously close second to posts. This isnā€™t about playing with the algo, btw - this is about actively participating in real conversations and meeting others to learn with. Iā€™ve made friends, had fab discussions and generated post ideas simply through comments.

Pick 10 people (with humble followings) you love learning from, hit the bell on their profile to get notified when they post, then comment authentically if (and only if) you can contribute a point of view. PS: ā€œagree!ā€ or anything by ChatGPT doesnā€™t count.

šŸ’š focus on what matters

Iā€™ve had a few posts go viral, and let me tell yā€™all: itā€™s overwhelming. Not only do a bunch of randoms follow you (whoā€™ll never become clients or friends), but youā€™re suddenly inundated with comments / DMs youā€™ll feel compelled to respond to.

Focus on what matters to you: whether thatā€™s building authentic relationships, improving written communication, keeping your brain sharp or learning.

If you hate making carousels (me) or cold DMā€™ing (also me), DONā€™T DO IT. Do what brings you joy and, above all, makes you a consistent, effective user on the platform.

šŸŽ from my ops toolbox

For the #SmoothOperators: each week in addition to a key theme, I share one tool helping me run a lean, cheap yet cheerful business. None of these are sponsored; theyā€™re simply tools I chose after lots of researching (so you donā€™t have to).

Staying on brand, what do I use to write?

šŸ§° In my toolbox: Obsidian (free)

I could shout about Obsidian forever, knowing full-well Iā€™ve only scratched the surface of all its brilliant functionality.

The biggest wins for me are:

  • Itā€™s offline, and in my case, in dark mode meaning zero distractions or friction. I get SO much written on Obsidian.

  • I can make folders for DAYS (which my brain loves), then connect rambles in the form of nodes to bigger, thematic nodes. Obsidian then outputs a visual representation of your brain for easy connection and flow.

  • Itā€™s a second brain that adapts to you vs. other writing apps that make you feel forced to adapt to them.

I havenā€™t dabbled in these yet, but Obsidian aficionados also swear by the Canvas feature and both community / efficiency plugins. Eventual review to come.

If youā€™re interested, this article by an Obsidian pro is a great place to start.

šŸ‘‘ misfit wisdom nuggets

šŸ‘¼šŸ» Each week, we feature a minority misfit answering: if you could do it all again knowing what you know now, what would you tell your younger self?

āœšŸ¼ Selena Coles, legendary human and Founder of BUILD Networks for Good, writes:

ā€œFocus less on making the ā€œright decision.ā€

I spent a lot of time in anguish trying to figure out if I was going to the ā€œrightā€ university, getting the ā€œright jobā€, collecting the right experiences. And you know what? I often picked wrong. We arenā€™t as good at decision making as we think we are. 

For example, I probably wouldnā€™t sign up to be a nanny for four kids under eight in Paris, knowing how it turned out. Iā€™ve never been so depressed and lonely, but I managed to learn some French, which offered many opportunities personally and professionally. 

Iā€™m not an ā€œeverything happens for a reasonā€ person but thereā€™s some relief in letting go a bit. There are so many sliding door moments but also so many opportunities to course correct.

Actually, I probably still need this advice today.ā€

šŸ“£ HEY MISFIT! If youā€™d like to be featured in an upcoming issue, email me with your answer to this question and LinkedIn profile. Letā€™s learn together šŸ«¶šŸ¼

Thanks for joining episode 12, misfits! As always, Iā€™m only ever an email away for questions / comments / thoughts šŸ«¶šŸ¼

Before you go, let me know what you thought of this issue with the pulse check below! Good intent feedback is always welcome ā¬‡ļø

xo, Neds

vibe check on the minority misfit:

how did you find today's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.